The Membership Economy
Find Your Superusers, Master the Forever Transaction, and Build Recurring Revenue
by Robbie Kellman Baxter
“The Membership Economy is a brilliant and timely book that will change the way you think about business.”
“A must-read for anyone who wants to understand the future of business.”
Why Your Customers Would Rather Rent Than Own
Think about your media consumption. Ten years ago, you probably owned a shelf full of DVDs and CDs. Today, you almost certainly subscribe to Netflix, Spotify, or both. Think about fitness. You could just own a stationary bike, but thousands are paying over $40 a month for a Peloton membership. This massive shift isn't just a change in technology; it's a profound change in our relationship with business. We are moving from a world of one-time transactions to one of ongoing relationships. We want access, not assets. We want belonging, not just a product.
This global economic transformation has a name: The Membership Economy. In her foundational book on the topic, consultant and strategist Robbie Kellman Baxter provides the playbook for this new world. She argues that the most successful businesses of the 21st century will not be the ones that sell the most units, but the ones that build the most loyal and engaged communities. It’s a guide to moving beyond the transactional treadmill and building a business that people join, and never want to leave.
What You'll Learn
The critical difference between a simple subscription and a true membership.
Why today’s consumers increasingly prefer ongoing access over one-time ownership.
The "Forever Promise" that forms the heart of any successful membership model.
How companies like Netflix, Peloton, and Amazon Prime build unbreakable loyalty.
The key steps to transforming your business into a membership-driven organization.
It's Not a Subscription, It's a Relationship
The first and most important distinction Baxter makes is between a subscription and a membership. They are not the same thing.
A subscription is a pricing tactic. You pay a recurring fee for access to a product or service, like a monthly magazine subscription. The relationship is purely transactional. If you stop paying, you stop getting the magazine.
A membership, on the other hand, is a relationship. It’s about creating a sense of belonging and identity. A great example is the difference between a generic gym and a CrossFit box. You have a subscription to a 24-hour gym; you get a key fob and access to the equipment. You have a membership at CrossFit. You are part of a community with a shared language ("WOD," "AMRAP"), common goals, and a powerful sense of identity. The monthly fee is just the ticket to admission into the tribe.
This is the core of the Membership Economy. It’s a mindset shift from "How do I get the next sale?" to "How do I solve my customer's problem forever?"
The "Forever Promise": The Heart of Membership
Every successful membership organization is built on what Baxter calls a "Forever Promise." This is the ongoing commitment you make to your members. It's the core value proposition that they can count on as long as they remain a member.
Netflix's promise: You'll always have something great to watch.
Amazon Prime's promise: We'll make your life more convenient with fast, free shipping and a host of other benefits.
A professional association's promise: We will help you advance and succeed in your career.
A young financial planner I know struggled with one-off project fees. He reframed his business around a "Forever Promise": "I will be your family's trusted financial partner for life, guiding you through every stage." He now charges a monthly membership fee. His clients don't just get a financial plan; they get ongoing peace of mind and a permanent ally. His revenue is now predictable, and his client relationships are deeper than ever. Defining your Forever Promise is the first step to building a membership model.
The Membership Model Checklist
Use this list, inspired by Baxter's framework, to see if your business has what it takes to build a successful membership.
A Recurring Problem or Goal: What ongoing customer need are you solving? (e.g., staying fit, being entertained, growing a career).
A Clear "Forever Promise": What is the long-term commitment you are making to your members? Can you state it in a single sentence?
A Welcoming Onboarding Process: How do you welcome new members and guide them to experience the core value immediately? A good onboarding can slash churn.
A Sense of Community: How can members connect with the organization and, just as importantly, with each other? Think forums, live events, or member directories.
A Stream of Ongoing Value: What new benefits, content, or features are you consistently providing to justify the recurring fee and keep members engaged?
The Right Metrics: Are you obsessing over member churn rate, lifetime value (LTV), and engagement, or are you still stuck on transactional metrics like customer acquisition cost (CAC)?
Building the Membership: The Member Lifecycle
Transitioning to a membership model requires a different approach to the entire customer journey.
1. The "On-Ramp" (Acquisition): The goal isn't to trick someone into a subscription. It's to let them experience the value of membership before they commit. This is why "freemium" models and free trials are so powerful. Spotify lets you listen for free with ads. They are so confident you’ll love the experience that a percentage of users will happily pay to upgrade. The free version is not a cost center; it's a powerful marketing engine.
2. The Welcome Mat (Onboarding): This is the most critical and often-overlooked stage. Baxter emphasizes that the first few days of a membership determine whether a customer will stay for years or churn out in a month. A great onboarding process is a guided tour. It shows the new member exactly how to get the most value from their membership. It might be a series of welcome emails, a personal check-in call, or an interactive setup wizard. The goal is to get them to an "aha!" moment as quickly as possible.
3. The Ongoing Relationship (Engagement & Retention): In the Membership Economy, the sale is just the beginning. The real work is in keeping members engaged. This is where companies like Peloton are masters. You don't just buy a bike; you join a movement. You have live classes with instructors who become celebrities, leaderboards that foster competition, and passionate online communities. Peloton is constantly adding new classes, new music, and new features, always giving members a reason to come back. They are delivering on their "Forever Promise" of making fitness engaging and exciting.
Your First Steps into the Membership Economy
Shifting to a membership model can feel daunting, but you can start small.
Identify a Recurring Problem: Look at your best customers. What is an ongoing pain point they have? Is there a way you could solve it with a recurring relationship instead of a series of one-time transactions?
Draft Your "Forever Promise": Spend an hour brainstorming what long-term value you could commit to providing. What would a "for life" relationship with your customers look like?
Create a Free "On-Ramp": What could you offer for free to give potential members a taste of your value? A weekly email newsletter with insider tips? A private LinkedIn group for your best customers? Start building the community first.
Just Ask: Survey your most loyal customers. Ask them directly: "What ongoing services or support would you be willing to pay a monthly or annual fee for?" Their answers might surprise you and reveal a clear path forward.
Final Reflections
The Membership Economy is a must-read for any business leader trying to navigate the modern marketplace. Robbie Kellman Baxter provides a clear and compelling roadmap for a fundamental shift in business strategy. The future does not belong to companies that simply transact with anonymous customers; it belongs to those that build loyal, passionate, and engaged communities of members. By moving your focus from the single sale to the "forever transaction," you can build a more resilient, more predictable, and ultimately more profitable business, creating an organization that your customers will see as an indispensable part of their lives.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!
