Start With No
The Negotiating Tools that the Pros Don't Want You to Know
by Jim Camp
“A master negotiator has distilled his no-nonsense insights in this brilliant how-to guide. Start with No will become required reading for anyone who bargains for a living.”
“With anecdotes and advice surefire for today’s business environment, Start with No takes the intimidation out of negotiating by engaging your inner negotiator and allowing you to regain control in any situation.”
Whether we're asking our boss for a raise, haggling over a house purchase, or just coordinating team responsibilities, we're all deal-makers constantly engaged in negotiations. Yet most of us instinctively dread these confrontations and approach them with trepidation and conflict-avoidance. We mistakenly view compromise as victory.
In his landmark book "Start with No," Jim Camp flips the script on conventional negotiating assumptions. Based on his decades as a top-tier FBI hostage negotiator facing extreme, high-stakes scenarios, Camp advocates adopting an entirely counterintuitive mindset - starting with the word "no" and working towards "yes." Here's his game-changing philosophy:
The Power of the Word "No"
In most negotiations, we start making concessions right away hoping to be seen as reasonable and find common ground. But Camp argues this approach puts you on your heels from the beginning, allowing the other side to instantly anchor the discussion on their terms.
"We've been brainwashed into believing it's rude to say no...but no represents infinity—it allows for infinite possibilities."
Starting with No gives you a psychological advantage by establishing the precedent that you'll only accept outcomes meeting your needs and standards. It frames the negotiation as a process to convince you rather than you pleading your case.
Three Key Negotiation Phases
While the typical assumptions are that negotiating is all about arguing and counter-arguing, Camp breaks the process into three distinct phases that unfold sequentially:
Framing Phase - Establishing trust, rapport, comfort, and a collaborative spirit. No positions are staked.
No Phase - Stating your "no" position by clearly laying out your core needs/grievances without negotiating yet.
Yeah-No Dance Phase - The back-and-forth exchange where you strategically use calibrated "No" responses to shape incremental concessions and "Yeah" to move towards alignment.
Too many negotiations get stuck adversarially in the third phase and miss setting up the first two stages. Camp emphasizes mastering the cadence and flow between the phases to flex between empathy mode and strategy mode.
"No" as a Tactic, Not a Rejection
The common fear in negotiations is saying "no" and being seen as inflexible or combative. But Camp shows how to use surgical doses of the word "no" as a tactical maneuver rather than a harsh rejection.
He shares frameworks for using calibrated "No" statements in response to unacceptable offers or demands to make counterparties pause, shift their approach, and make additional concessions:
"I'm sorry, no, that's just not going to work for me..." "No, that doesn't meet my needs for..." "No, I can't support that because..."
Each "no" has to be accompanied with a rationale or problem statement. The powerful "No" prompts the other side to revise terms or address your concerns more fully before proceeding.
Labels vs. Needs
A critical distinction Camp makes is learning to negotiate around articulated needs rather than hardened labels or positions from either side. "I need" statements reveal motivations and leave room for potential solutions rather than boxing yourself into a corner. For example:
Unhelpful Label: "I want a 15% increase in compensation this year." Underlying Need: "I need my contributions to be appropriately valued and stay motivated."
This shift opens up room for creative problem-solving around needs, not just debating incompatible positions.
The F.I.R.M. Model
Perhaps Camp's signature framework is the F.I.R.M model - 4 key principles for successful negotiations:
F - Fairness: Authentically recognize the fact both sides have reasonable desires to address. Don't view the other side as adversaries.
I - Interests: Separate ego and positioning from underlying interests and needs. Problems persist until these deeper drivers are explored.
R - Resolutions: Stubbornly stick to finding resolutions with no compromise rather than premature agreement or middle ground. Keep dancing.
M - Mutual: No resolution is successful unless both sides feel like they've won and achieved their key interests.
Over and over, the goal is to lead parties towards mutual resolutions that satisfy core needs in a fair, interest-based manner - without compromise.
Mastering the "No-Master" Mindset
At its heart, Start with No is about adopting a more confidence, empowered "No-Master" mindset that flips the script on conventional pushover tactics. As Camp eloquently closes the book:
"Through discipline, commitment, and a clearly defined plan, you will take control of your fears and your needs. You will become a No-Master and declare your personal freedom from the misery of compromise."
By learning to leverage the power of "No", you turn negotiations into structured problem-solving sessions rather than zero-sum battles of conflicting positions. You unlock your ability to shape win-win resolutions around mutual interests without compromising core standards.
It's a transformative approach for both professional life, where you're constantly negotiating with colleagues, partners, and vendors, and personal realms like buying decisions and conflict resolution. Master the mentally tough art of kicking off with "No" and you'll find yourself thriving through more mutually prosperous outcomes for years to come.
Business Floss is reader-supported. When you use our links we may earn an affiliate commission that helps us keep the site running. Thank you for your support!
